Thanksgiving Day as a Persecuted Christian: When a Chinese Christian Reminded Me What Thanksgiving Really Means

I sat down across from the wife of a visiting pastor at my church. Let’s call her Ruth. Ruth was a recent friend with whom I share a special connection: we’re both Chinese Christians. She was born and raised in China, and I was born and raised in America.

As the current Chinese administration tightens restrictions on house churches in China, Christians find it increasingly difficult to even hold prayer meetings — something as simple as gathering for Bible study can invite government scrutiny. For many Christians in China, Sunday worship looks like attending church in a rented apartment building room and whispering hymns of praise as police officers stroll the premises, listening for “anti-China propaganda” or “anti-CCP” behavior.

Ruth, her husband, and their children came to the United States for pastoral studies, but they left China under government pressure, uncertain if or when they could ever return.

“Are you guys doing anything for Thanksgiving?” I asked casually in Chinese.

Then suddenly, remembering that Thanksgiving is a uniquely American holiday, I asked, “Do you know what Thanksgiving is?”

She smiled eagerly. “Yes, we celebrate Thanksgiving.”

“Chinese people celebrate Thanksgiving now?” I was confused.

“No,” she replied. “But our family has always celebrated Thanksgiving every year on our own.”

I was intrigued. “How do you celebrate? Thanksgiving is an American holiday!”

“Yes, but it is a Christian holiday, so only our family celebrates it. We cook a simple meal at home, and we take turns talking about things we are thankful for.”

I was stunned.

How many times had I taken Thanksgiving for granted? How often had I paused to meditate on the meaning of Thanksgiving before stuffing myself with mashed potatoes and whipped cream served with pumpkin pie?

Here I was, having grown up celebrating Thanksgiving every year with my Chinese immigrant mother and my Southern American father, listening to a Chinese Christian embrace a foreign holiday, not because of the country it comes from, but because of the Kingdom to which it points.

This dear sister in Christ had celebrated Thanksgiving year after year in a country across the world under threat of mockery and persecution. Ruth was not familiar with my turkey traditions and mashed potatoes. She was just excited to praise Jesus.

How remarkable that a Christian living under religious persecution could recognize the spiritual significance of an American holiday of which many Americans are now unaware.

I wondered what Ruth would think of the way Thanksgiving is often celebrated in America today, where the abundance of food, festivities, and shopping easily overshadows the very gratitude the holiday was meant to inspire.

So why do Americans celebrate Thanksgiving? More importantly, why does it matter to Christians?

We celebrate Thanksgiving because of a group of persecuted Christians who left Holland and sailed to the New World, seeking religious liberty so they could worship God freely. Their ambition was not without cost.

Governor William Bradford, recalling their departure, wrote of how they, knowing they were pilgrims, lifted their eyes toward heaven, regarding it as their dearest country, and found peace in that eternal hope.

In the autumn of 1621, after enduring a brutal winter which claimed the lives of nearly half their company, the surviving Pilgrims gathered to celebrate their first successful harvest alongside members of the Wampanoag people, whose assistance had been vital to their survival.

In a letter to a friend, one of the Plymouth leaders, Edward Winslow, wrote, “by the goodness of God we are so far from want that we are partakers of plenty.”

The first Thanksgiving was a day of humble, grateful recognition of God’s power.

How far the modern American Thanksgiving holiday has departed from the original piety of the Pilgrims! How far we have wandered from celebrating the Sovereign Hand of God! Instead, much of America focuses on Thanksgiving Day parades, thousands of calories, and Black Friday deals.

While we can take joy in gathering around the table and celebrating a wonderful holiday, I wonder how often we allow our blessings to become the center of our celebration instead of praising the Giver of those blessings. Even as Christians, we are not immune to allowing gratitude to give way to consumption, service to selfishness, and piety to pageantry.

How striking, then, to find that same disposition of humble gratitude as the Pilgrims on the face of a persecuted Chinese Christian. Ruth was grateful, even just for the opportunity to celebrate a Chrisitan holiday freely, without any fear of imprisonment or arrest.

The irony should not be lost on us.

As I sat across from Ruth that Wednesday evening, I was convicted by how casually I had treated a holiday that she treasured so deeply. Thanksgiving for me had become, instead, a launching pad into my favorite season: Christmas. Between my excitement for the lights and trees and glamorous parties, I had abandoned the practice of gratitude to the God who gave me everything I have.

This Thanksgiving Day, I certainly do not intend to forego my mashed potatoes or my whipped cream served with pumpkin pie. Yet, I pray that we would remember the simple gratitude of fifty-three Pilgrims who gathered together to thank God. Let us imitate the devotion of those few surviving families who invited their kind, new Wampanoag friends to their feast and showed them what it meant to live like Christ.

Finally, I pray that, somewhere between the turkey and the stuffing, the festivities and familiar traditions, Ruth’s story would remind us to look beyond the holiday itself and reflect with renewed gratitude on the extraordinary privilege of religious liberty we so often take for granted.

The Pilgrims gave thanks after enduring suffering and persecution. Ruth and her family gave thanks in a country where their faith in God could cost everything. How much more should we, as free Christians in a country where our religious liberties are protected, take advantage of such a holiday to proclaim God’s blessings in our lives and country and teach others to do the same!

As Governor Bradford wrote, “Thus out of small beginnings greater things have been produced by His hand that made all things of nothing, and gives being to all things that are; and as one small candle may light a thousand, so the light here kindled hath shone to many … let the glorious name of Jehovah have all the praise.”

Related